PDA

View Full Version : First day Motorola Cliq Review (positive)



LpLayer
11-04-2009, 05:04 AM
I received my cliq today, I have a relative that works for T-mobile so I received quite a discount on it.
To start, my first impressions of the device were quite positive, the phone felt great on my hands and was more aesthetically pleasing than the G1. (my previous phone.) I opted for the titanium finish and do not regret it. The phone is thinner than the g1 yet a bit heavier, not like a brick, it makes the device feel sturdy.
The face of the device only has 3 buttons: Home, Menu, and Back it is missing the pickup and end call buttons found on the G1. The device also has a dedicated camera button on the side, a power/sleep button, a rocker button to control volume levels, and a switch that activates and deactivates a silent vibrating state, also motorola made the smart decision to include a regular 3.5 mm headphone jack, so no adapters are necessary.

When you power up the phone you are taken to a moto blur account set up screen, this takes no time. Once that is complete, you are instructed to link accounts you may have including: Google, Twitter, Last.FM, Photobucket, Picassa, Facebook, Yahoo mail, Any other email, and Myspace. Being 20 I have all but a Yahoo mail account, so I went ahead and linked all accounts, this process took about 8 minutes. Once the phone completely booted and everything was up and running, I played around with the UI, which looks better than the stock android. The icons look sharper and the screen itself seems a bit less contrasty and the color scheme works well. The phone comes preloaded with a few apps and widgets. There are a bunch of widgets set up on your home screen by default, but if you have used an android device keeping them or deleting them is as easy as drag and drop. There is quite an array of widgets including a messaging widget, weather, a happenings widget etc. All the widgets have a nice look to them and serve a purpose for example the happenings widget shows chronologically new updates that have been posted by friends on facebook and myspace.

The thing that impressed me the most from the moto blur integration is how contacts are handled. The phone matches contact names with according names on facebook, myspace, and twitter. The phone asks you what social site would you like your contacts pictures to display from. It all takes a few minutes but all contacts link into one "super contact" list with easy access to their telephone number, and social sites information.

On the hardware side of things, as I mentioned the phone feels quite sturdy. The camera works quite well and is rated at 5 mega pixels. I took a few sample shots and the camera boots quicker and has a quicker reaction rate than that of the G1. I have not yet tested the video, since the time I have had so far has been limited.

Now we come to a very important part the keyboard, which overall works excellent. The keys are set up in your typical qwerty manner but are spaced together. From pictures it may appear that the phone has small keys but it does not. The keys are domed and have a good feel to them, my only gripe is that there aren't any dedicated number keys, so to type numbers you will be required to press "alt" a few times. The keys are also well lit and visible. There is also a D-pad on the keyboard which works well and can be useful.

Final Thoughts: As you may have noticed there is a certain aspect of this phone that seems to be its main factor, yes social networking.
I believe that someone who really is not into such internet phenomena will not benefit greatly from this phone. Also this phone may have limited appeal because it may not be deemed "professional" by some. However, I personally have enjoyed the phone thus far. It is quite an update from the G1 both hardware wise and in general appeal. I liked what motorola has done, and yes lets face it, this phone does have a defined target audience. With that said, I can assume that people will look into this device if any of the above seems like something they would love their phone to do. As of now I am quite content and will continue to comment on the future I will endure with this phone.

thefran1996
11-04-2009, 05:20 AM
Hope you Enjoy it :D

ahugo68
11-04-2009, 08:05 AM
Great review. I went to tmobile yesterday to get either the cliq or mytouch. After playing with both I want a trackball and I didn't like the overall feel to the cliq. But I hope it works well for you. thanks for the review.

scrannel
11-04-2009, 08:16 AM
Three simple questions, Lplayer - 1) Can you transfer files (both ways) using Bluetooth? 2) Does the email app allow you to receive and send ANY attachments even if you don't have an app to run them? 3) Is there an office app built in that will allow you to read Office dos and PDF?

Thanks

tythoward
11-04-2009, 09:42 AM
I ordered mine on yesterday and should be receiving it on Friday. I'll see if I like it better than the G1.

LpLayer
11-04-2009, 10:20 AM
Great review. I went to tmobile yesterday to get either the cliq or mytouch. After playing with both I want a trackball and I didn't like the overall feel to the cliq. But I hope it works well for you. thanks for the review. You're welcome! If you did get the Mytouch I hope you enjoy that phone as well.


Three simple questions, Lplayer - 1) Can you transfer files (both ways) using Bluetooth? 2) Does the email app allow you to receive and send ANY attachments even if you don't have an app to run them? 3) Is there an office app built in that will allow you to read Office dos and PDF?

Thanks
So far out of the 3 questions I know it does not come with a pre built app to view office documents. I shall however test the other 2 inquiries today.

Kings to me
11-04-2009, 10:20 AM
Good review. I still would like to feel one in my hands before I switch phones or I just may wait a few more months to see what else pops up. Thanks again.

scrannel
11-04-2009, 10:25 AM
So far out of the 3 questions I know it does not come with a pre built app to view office documents. I shall however test the other 2 inquiries today.

Thanks, appreciate it.

drewbdope
11-07-2009, 03:21 PM
I've had the cliq for a few weeks now and I love it too. Its my 1st go at an android phone. I love the MotoBlur feature, but I don't use my networks hardcore. I really want to get more into the opening of the OS. It functions great so far.

Fourtysixand10
11-10-2009, 01:55 AM
I went from a G1 to the Cliq. A few observations:

-The keyboard took me some time to get used to. Still not quite used to it. The space bar is the biggest issue for me. Too low and too small.

-Contact list. When you first link all your accounts you see duplicate entries. If you have a friend on gmail, Facebook and Myspace you will see one for each. You can link them into one which is great. Once you do that you can see everyone's social networking updates on one page. "Happenings", very neat.

-Screen. Very sharp but too sensitive. I'm constantly trying to scroll and selecting instead. It can be very annoying. Maybe it's just me.

-phone calls. Much improved over the G1. The proximity sensor is a great idea. No need to unlock the phone to input on the dial pad. Switching to speaker is also right at your finger tips.

Overall it seem must more faster and responsive than my G1. I'm surprised since I would think that Blur would take up lots of memory. It must have something to do with the on board memory. I love the solid feel.

I'm quite happy with this phone :D

Jaysil18
11-10-2009, 02:23 AM
I was thinking about getting it but then i heard about the droid and might just switch to verizon . Plus i went to walmart yesterday and they had it and its really ugly and kiddish looking . I like the g1 looks better .

cwcentral
11-10-2009, 04:07 PM
Cliq owners, so without using the device heavily with the social networking notifications: how long is battery life? better than the G1?

Also, are you guys finding the slider to be a sturdier mechanism than the G1?

I think both (battery life & slider) are the most complains about the G1 and if the Cliq is better, then I just may switch.

OntheGround
11-15-2009, 04:02 AM
Cliq owners, so without using the device heavily with the social networking notifications: how long is battery life? better than the G1?

Also, are you guys finding the slider to be a sturdier mechanism than the G1?

I think both (battery life & slider) are the most complains about the G1 and if the Cliq is better, then I just may switch.

Took the words right outta my mouth. I was talking to a rep at the Tmo store the other day and trying to convince them I deserved an upgrade (first guy was trying to work with me but he got called away and the second was a jerk).

I was enjoying the phone they had there, preferred the white as a matter of fact, but pretty much had the same questions you're asking here... how's the battery life and the slider? I didn't have much time with the phone but i actually felt I preferred the slide on the G1, the slid mechanism on the Cliq felt a little flimsy.

Aside from that, for those who upgraded from a G1 to a Cliq, overall what is better, what do you miss? Should I hold out until my contract comes up in four months for another phone to come out, or is this as good as it gets? I'll be going to spend a semester on the East Coast starting in January and was hoping to upgrade before then if it's worthwhile.

Wilco
11-15-2009, 04:49 PM
I'm coming up on my year anniversary I've had the G1. Love the functionality of G1, but hate the chin and the constant lag and memory constraints. I'm thinking I need to hold off any T-Mo upgrade, since my perception of all Android phones at T-Mo (Cliq, MT3G) are they are about the same performance as G1. In fact, Behold 2 seems to be about the same performance level as G1.

I want a powerful phone, like Droid. I love the notion of a seperate GPU, and plenty of memory. Does the Cliq seem laggy, and memory constrained? I constantly have issues with my G1, where I press an icon, and due to memory constraints, it tries to grab a different icon. Taskiller is my most important application on the G1, cause without it, my G1 would lock up constantly. I don't want the same with a new phone. I want power. I want a large display. I want more memory than I could use. I think I want a Droid. Does T-Mo have anything that will satisfy?

Wilco
11-16-2009, 01:33 PM
just read a review on Engadget that talked about the display being too small, and non-responsive. They also felt the processor was under-powered. Wish T-Mobile read that review, cause I can't see upgrading from G1 to that phone. I'm less interested in the social networking then I am with a phone that can scale and a display that is larger.

ren857
11-16-2009, 09:06 PM
just read a review on Engadget that talked about the display being too small, and non-responsive. They also felt the processor was under-powered. Wish T-Mobile read that review, cause I can't see upgrading from G1 to that phone. I'm less interested in the social networking then I am with a phone that can scale and a display that is larger.

Do you normally base your purchases off of one online review? Engadget isn't the only site that writes phone reviews.

Wilco
11-17-2009, 01:07 AM
not normally. But understand, I didn't like the size of the display, the memory limitations, and the underpowered processor to begin with. Most reviews I've read of the Cliq center primarily on the software itself with very little dedicated to the processing power of the phone.

Where the concept of Blur is somewhat interesting to me, I've always been more interested in the processing power of my smartphones. I recognize the processing ability of the Cliq and that review pretty much confirmed my concerns. I'm a little surprised when folks on this board are that impressed with the processing power of the Cliq. Ultimately, I've tried to get excited by the Cliq, because I'm ready and willing to upgrade. When I read that review and the concerns they had with the display size and functionality, and the lag and processing issues, that was enough for me to pause on upgrading to any of the current T-Mo android phones and to continue to hope T-Mo can come up with something that will address my needs more closely. Clearly (and with frustration) the Cliq, MT3G, and pending Behold2 do not.

BORIStheBLADE
11-22-2009, 08:34 PM
I've had the Cliq since the day it came out. I got rid of all the social widgets it came with and have the GPS off most of the time and the battery still wont last 24 hours.

I'd say I use it more for texting and phone calls with the apps, but not heavy app use the battery last about about 12-14 hours.

Rajiim
11-23-2009, 12:56 AM
I had the MT3g from day one......Sold it the day the Cliq came out and bought two Cliq's!!
The MT3g constantly had Force Close errors and also the battery sucked. With my Cliq I have Good battery life. I do charge it when not being used but have actually gone two days without a recharge. You don't have to use all the social apps. I use the internet, play games and Love my Cliq!! Only complaint.....Still on 1.5!! I had the new 1.6 upgrade on the MT3g. That I miss. Aside from that.....Great Phone!!!

As with both phones MT3g & the Cliq....... BLUETOOTH SUPPORT!!! Come On!!!!!!

thundermax
11-23-2009, 10:57 AM
Cliq owners, so without using the device heavily with the social networking notifications: how long is battery life? better than the G1?

Also, are you guys finding the slider to be a sturdier mechanism than the G1?


I use almost all of the social networking features of the Cliq and it it is still phenomenally better than my G1 for battery life.

The slider is definitely sturdier. It is a solid device that I have droppedmore than once. The slider on my G1 has always felt wobbly.

I do like the spacing of the keys on the G1 better. But for overall user experience I'm using the Cliq.

themadsquirrel
11-25-2009, 05:55 PM
Cliq owners, so without using the device heavily with the social networking notifications: how long is battery life? better than the G1?

Also, are you guys finding the slider to be a sturdier mechanism than the G1?

I think both (battery life & slider) are the most complains about the G1 and if the Cliq is better, then I just may switch.I had both the G1 and the MT3G and I now have the Cliq. Battery life is very good, I typically get about 16 hours- and this is with wi-fi on.

It's a very sturdy phone and isn't as laggy as the MT3G was.

I feel that the Droid is kind of an ugly looking phone and I don't like Verizon so I went with the Cliq. I have had no issues.

clique
11-27-2009, 03:54 PM
Totally agree with the review. I have had the phone for sometime now got it early for working with tmo, coming from a non-smartphone (sony ericsson w200 don't laugh lol) its a great phone, the only downside to it is that we haven't had any announcement for an Android upgrade to 1.6 nor 2.0, but aside that I'm really happy with the cliq

bikedogrun
11-28-2009, 09:38 PM
I had both the G1 and the MT3G and I now have the Cliq. Battery life is very good, I typically get about 16 hours- and this is with wi-fi on.

It's a very sturdy phone and isn't as laggy as the MT3G was.

I feel that the Droid is kind of an ugly looking phone and I don't like Verizon so I went with the Cliq. I have had no issues.Hey Squirrel - totally agree with your observations.

Also coming from a MT3G (and iPhone)... the Cliq is definitely less laggy, in fact; not laggy at all (for me). Battery life is also better than the MT3G; not outstanding but reasonably decent (heavy WiFi user too).

I really, REALLY wanted to like the Droid but found it very underwhelming (and ugly). The keyboard is pretty poor too. Sure; having Android 2.0 would be cool & all (Google Maps w/ Nav) but it just didn't feel right in my hand at all... and I would have been saddled with 2 yrs of Verizon's high prices and customer arrogance.

Very happy with the Cliq (after 3 weeks now)... ;)

/BD :cool:

djunio
01-15-2010, 11:09 PM
is it just me or is the cliq stupid fast